Thanksgiving Desserts Columbus Loves

As the leaves in Columbus turn brilliant shades of red and gold and the air becomes crisp and inviting, there’s one thing on everyone’s mind: Thanksgiving. It is a cherished holiday where everyone gathers with their friends and family to express gratitude and share a meal that warms our hearts and bellies. While the turkey often takes center stage, remember the grand finale – the Thanksgiving desserts. Columbus knows a thing or two about sweet treats, and in this blog, we’re about to begin a mouthwatering journey through the city’s most beloved Thanksgiving desserts. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, prepare to indulge in a delectable assortment of Columbus’ favorite Thanksgiving sweets. 

Ten Thanksgiving Desserts Columbus Loves: 

Pumpkin Pie from Schmidt’s Sausage Haus: 

To truly appreciate the essence of a Columbus Thanksgiving dessert, we start with a timeless classic – pumpkin pie. Few things capture the essence of fall and Thanksgiving quite like a slice of velvety pumpkin pie, and Schmidt’s Sausage Haus has perfected this culinary masterpiece. Their rendition is more than just a dessert; it’s a slice of tradition, lovingly crafted with locally sourced ingredients. You’ll taste the rich, earthy flavors of Ohio’s autumn with each bite, making it an essential part of any Columbus Thanksgiving spread. 

Buckeye Brownies at North Market: 

In Ohio, paying tribute to the state’s iconic Buckeye tree is a sweet tradition. Enter the Buckeye Brownies at North Market – a delectable fusion of rich, chocolatey goodness and the beloved peanut butter and chocolate Buckeye candy. These brownies are more than just a dessert; they’re a local favorite, a cherished symbol of Ohio pride, and a bite-sized slice of heaven. Finding them at North Market is an experience that will undoubtedly leave you craving more. 

Apple Crisp from Clintonville Farmers’ Market: 

Thanksgiving is a time for comfort, and what’s more comforting than a freshly prepared, warm plate of apple crisp? But this isn’t just apple crisp; it’s a Columbus gem at the Clintonville Farmers’ Market. Here, you’ll discover a delicious dessert with Ohio’s finest apples. Each spoonful carries the sweet aroma of fall, making it a dessert that will warm your heart and soul. 

Baklava from Lavash Cafe: 

For those seeking a unique twist on their Thanksgiving desserts, look no further than the baklava from Lavash Cafe. This Middle Eastern delicacy is a dessert that transcends borders and cultures. Layers of flaky pastry, sweet honey, and crunchy nuts combine to create a symphony of flavors and textures. It’s an irresistible option that adds an exotic touch to your Thanksgiving feast, proving that dessert can be a delicious journey of discovery. 

Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie at Fox in the Snow: 

Pecan pie is a Thanksgiving classic, but Fox in the Snow takes it to new heights with their Maple Bourbon Pecan Pie. This dessert is an elegant fusion of flavors – the rich, nutty essence of pecans, maple syrup’s sweetness, and bourbon’s depth. It’s a sophisticated dessert that harmonizes sweet and savory notes, making it the perfect grand finale for your Columbus Thanksgiving dinner

Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes from Pattycake Bakery: 

Cupcakes are the epitome of single-serving delights, and when fall arrives, so do Pattycake Bakery’s Pumpkin Spice Cupcakes. These little treats are like bites of autumn captured in cake form. With each moist and flavorful taste, you’ll experience the essence of fall – the warmth of spices, the sweetness of pumpkin, and the comfort of home-baked goodness. They’re a convenient and indulgent way to celebrate Thanksgiving’s flavors. 

Sweet Potato Cheesecake from The Cheesecake Girl: 

Sweet potato lovers, prepare to have your taste buds delighted. The Cheesecake Girl’s Sweet Potato Cheesecake is a creamy, dreamy dessert poised to become a new Thanksgiving tradition. It’s a masterful blend of sweet potato’s natural sweetness and the luscious creaminess of cheesecake. This dessert captures the essence of Thanksgiving in each heavenly bite. 

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie from Brown Bag Deli: 

In the world of desserts, few combinations are as legendary as chocolate and peanut butter. Brown Bag Deli takes this iconic duo to new heights with their Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie. It’s not just a slice of Columbus indulgence; it’s a decadent journey into dessert heaven. The velvety chocolate and the rich peanut butter blend flavors that will leave you craving more. 

Cranberry Orange Bread at Cherbourg Bakery: 

Cherbourg Bakery’s Cranberry Orange Bread is a delightful choice for those seeking a lighter option among the Thanksgiving desserts. It’s a harmonious combination of tart cranberries and zesty orange, creating a palate-refreshing treat after hearty home-cooked meals in Columbus Ohio. It’s a testament to the versatility of dessert and a reminder that sometimes simplicity is sheer perfection. 

Gourmet Donuts from Destination Donuts: 

If you’re not ready to commit to a whole slice of pie but still want to satisfy your sweet tooth, look no further than Destination Donuts. Their gourmet donuts offer a wide array of unique flavors and seasonal options that are sure to delight. From classic favorites to creative concoctions, these donuts provide a fun and indulgent way to conclude your Thanksgiving feast, leaving everyone with smiles. 


Thanksgiving in Columbus is not just about turkey and stuffing; it’s a celebration of diverse flavors and traditions, especially regarding dessert. From classic pumpkin pie to inventive treats like Buckeye Brownies and Sweet Potato Cheesecake, Columbus’ dessert scene is a delightful journey of taste and texture. As you gather around the table this Thanksgiving, don’t forget to leave room for the city’s most beloved Thanksgiving desserts. These sweet delights are a testament to the culinary creativity and rich traditions that make Columbus a lovely place to call home or visit during the holiday season. So, grab a fork and savor the flavors of Thanksgiving desserts that Columbus loves.